Editorial on M. Truzzi
Hi,
I´ve just read a couple of articles by M.Truzzi and he really sounds like a strong advocate for open-mindedness. But on the other hand science calls for being sceptic (in it´s true sense, opposed to pseudo-scepticism), not believing anything without sufficient evidence.
From what Mr. Truzzi saw, that might have been a chance-hit. From what he saw he could not conclude that you were not cheating on the Russian-Revolution target.
Let´s face the truth. What you showed to him was exciting, but did not come close to being sufficient evidence from a scientist´s point of view. A couple of months ago I would not have been convinced (or even impressed) by those two pieces of paper either.
We must always remember that we are the only ones to really know for sure what we do, how we do it, and that there is no cheating going on. We can´t expect anyone to belive in RV just because we show them to scraps of paper and tell them we did not cheat.
I must tell you that I was not convinced this RV-Stuff was worth a damn until I got to PLAYFAIR and did my session on the IO (Jupiter´s Moon) Target. And although I now believe RV is working the empirical scientist inside of me still want´s to see some statistical testing on a double-blind evaluation of my skeds (but I must admit that he has so far not been strong enough to overcome the other lazy parts of me).
So I think the editorial was quite unfair to Mr. Truzzi.
I think it would have been a much better Idea to contact him to talk about proceedings to produce convincing evidence instead of mocking him in an editorial. This man could really be helpful to our cause.
Jan.
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Aloha
I maintain that skeptics will never be convinced. Why waste the effort when we can be remote viewing for those who believe in the effectiveness of the skill and remote viewing application to help the world we live in.
Nice presentation Dick, great job Valtra.
peace
Banshee
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Hi Jan…
You make some very good points, and I agree with most of what you say.
But you would have had to be there.. to see the manner in which Professor Truzzi totally dismissed Mana’s work in an instant, without so much as mere curiosity. Despite his claims of being open, I really think his mind is made up.
The two examples shown in my editorial prove remote viewing, period. They were both done in front of witnesses, the viewer had no prior knowledge or the target, no frontloading whatsoever.
Prof. Truzzi did give us some good ideas about how to structure an experiment that could be presented for peer review. I will be contacting a Ph.D. at the University of Hawaii (head of the Psychology Dept.) to see about setting something up.
Aloha
Dick
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
I really think
his mind is made up.
Dear Dick:
I loved your editorial. It proves once again the old adage.
"Compelling reason will never convince blinding emotion."
Regards,
Geo. M.
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Aloha Jan,
I would take the opportunity to compliment what Professor Truzzi has been able to accomplish in his career.
I also think the reply that was given to Dick would not have been the reply given to Paul or Lyn had they been the ones to ask the questions that Dick asked. I feel Dick got the truth because he was an unknown.
This is a personal opinion and much like Dick’s editorial I am Skeptical of Professor Truzzi’s claim to being an Honest Skeptic. It looked to me in that moment that he became the Skeptic he warned us about in his lecture.
Regardless of his official position and his linkage to the RV community it seems he has made up his mind that Remote Viewing should be looked at in the greater sense of Psi or Clairvoyance. He makes the point of putting consideration of Remote Viewing in the case for Psi. He is a skeptic of Remote Viewing but he considers it Psi, which he is skeptical of. A conundrum to be sure.
I was disappointed to listen to an excellent lecture and then see the principals cast aside so quickly.
Aloha Glenn
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Aloha All!
I was very impressed with Prof. Truzzi’s lecture and was heartened by the message that he conveyed. He feels that there is some phenomenological evidence that Psi (and as such, Remote Viewing) may be true. However, he does also state that as such, there has not been any valid, double-blind studies done to scientifically prove its existence. In his opinion, the evidence presented to him so far, falls within allowable parameters of chance and coincidence. As a scientist, he would need some hard empirical data that substantiates the truth of Psi activity as something existing outside of coincidence.
I am not a statistician and can’t figure the probability factor of being able to "call" target for each of the two sessions in question here, ie, Catalina Island and Russian Revolution. So I can’t say whether it still falls within the "coincidence" range of probablity.
However, I do know, that in both incidences, I had absolutely no preconception or knowledge as to the nature of the target. So we must consider, how many possible targets could have been chosen to be tasked at these times? There were no preset lists of targets to my knowledge to be considered. But there are an infinite number of possible targets that could have been chosen! So in my poor logic, I had a 1 in infinite # chance of hitting target. In my mind, that makes a case for remote viewing. Any attempt to prove this through repeated RV sessions, would only determine my hit rate rather than the fact that remote viewing works.
The fact that Prof. Truzzi didn’t consider the validity of those two sessions, means that he is essentially calling the viewer a liar and a cheat. What else is there? Beyond that, it implies that the skeptic is in such a mind-lock that he can’t see outside his own box.
His thought processing is an endless closed-loop.
It is not to convince the skeptic that it is real but to actually put RVing to task so that it has application in reality. In other words, PROVE IT IN REALITY! Our efforts are better spent to find that missing child, uncover the mystery…..help improve the human condition in some way.
Aloha, Valtra
An honest skeptic or…..
someone just trying to draw attention to themselves?
If I see one more skeptic, who pulls all sorts of "end runs" and says one thing then does another……I’ll think I’ll puke!
How many skeptics so far have proven themselves to be nothing more than two faced lyers?
And yet, every skeptic the HRVG has come across as had a professional degree (if not more than one).
Where does it end? I think skeptics should be dismissed, regardless of their backround, since they’ll never be convinced, or if they should be proven wrong will find some way to wiggle out of it.
Truzzi is just one more, in a long line of skeptics that’s bound to show up and prove to the world how smart they are, while they contradict themselves, as Dick’s editorial have proven.
J.P.
Hi,
I´ve just read a couple of articles by M.Truzzi and he really sounds like a strong advocate for open-mindedness. But on the other hand science calls for being sceptic (in it´s true sense, opposed to pseudo-scepticism), not believing anything without sufficient evidence.
From what Mr. Truzzi saw, that might have been a chance-hit. From what he saw he could not conclude that you were not cheating on the Russian-Revolution target.
Let´s face the truth. What you showed to him was exciting, but did not come close to being sufficient evidence from a scientist´s point of view. A couple of months ago I would not have been convinced (or even impressed) by those two pieces of paper either.
We must always remember that we are the only ones to really know for sure what we do, how we do it, and that there is no cheating going on. We can´t expect anyone to belive in RV just because we show them to scraps of paper and tell them we did not cheat.
I must tell you that I was not convinced this RV-Stuff was worth a damn until I got to PLAYFAIR and did my session on the IO (Jupiter´s Moon) Target. And although I now believe RV is working the empirical scientist inside of me still want´s to see some statistical testing on a double-blind evaluation of my skeds (but I must admit that he has so far not been strong enough to overcome the other lazy parts of me).
So I think the editorial was quite unfair to Mr. Truzzi.
I think it would have been a much better Idea to contact him to talk about proceedings to produce convincing evidence instead of mocking him in an editorial. This man could really be helpful to our cause.
Jan.
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Good post Mana,
I also listened to Dr. Truzzi’s speech. When did science replace the "knowing"..that realm of intuition that is always right?….This realm existed long before the hallways of science became lined with skeptic gold…sometimes it is easier to call a flower a flower than go through the motions to disprove the flower ever existed.
He did indicate he was open minded; however when he saw your work, the rational ego grabbed his attention and the skeptical scientist rushed out before the one that made sense could speak.
aloha…
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
>
Good post Mana, I also listened to Dr. Truzzi’s speech. When did science replace the "knowing"..that realm of intuition that is always right?….This realm existed long before the hallways of science became lined with skeptic gold…sometimes it is easier to call a flower a flower than go through the motions to disprove the flower ever existed.
He did indicate he was open minded; however when he saw your work, the rational ego grabbed his attention and the skeptical scientist rushed out before the one that made sense could speak.
No, it was just the other way around. The one that made sense did not believe in it and the skeptical scientist did not get enough data have a clue.
aloha…
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Hi,
I picked some quotes to comment to.
Glenn Wrote:
This is a personal opinion and much like Dick’s editorial I am Skeptical of Professor Truzzi’s claim to being an Honest Skeptic. It looked to me in that moment that he became the Skeptic he warned us about in his lecture.
Me:
The Pseudo-Skeptic that Truzzi warned you about, is someone who has double-standards. When it comes to anomalies they will not accept scientific procedures, that are accepted for questions that fit into their frame of reference. Today parapsychological research takes precautions that are high above the standards of most other fields of research. But Pseudo-Skeptics will still not accept the results.
I think it is really important to keep that difference of skeptical Scientists and Pseudo-Skeptics in mind. Many (if not most) of the members of CSICOP (or the German GWUP) are Pseudo-Skeptcis. Parapsychologists like Putthoff or Targ have to be Skeptcis to do propper scientific Research.
Valtra Wrote:
I am not a statistician and can’t figure the probability factor of being able to "call" target for each of the two sessions in question here, ie, Catalina Island and Russian Revolution. So I can’t say whether it still falls within the "coincidence" range of probablity.
However, I do know, that in both incidences, I had absolutely no preconception or knowledge as to the nature of the target. So we must consider, how many possible targets could have been chosen to be tasked at these times? There were no preset lists of targets to my knowledge to be considered. But there are an infinite number of possible targets that could have been chosen! So in my poor logic, I had a 1 in infinite # chance of hitting target. In my mind, that makes a case for remote viewing. Any attempt to prove this through repeated RV sessions, would only determine my hit rate rather than the fact that remote viewing works.
Me:
Unfortunately, it´s not that simple. First of all, you don´t have an infinite number of targets. But the possible number of Targets is BIG. But many of those targets look quite similar. Your S3 on Catalina Island could have been from any island or any coastline. Your S3 on the Russian Revolution could have been from loads of different gatherings in front of some big building. That really cuts down the number of possibilities. Just go through all the targets you ever did and try to put them into categories of targets that share some similarities. You won´t come up with a very big number. If you had produced that Russian-Revolution S3 on the President Taft Session, would you have called it a hit? I bet you would, and so would I. When someone produces lots of sketches, there will be some chance hits.
But there are ways to do statistical research on RV. I have not made up my mind about the details though, but it kind of goes like this: You have a Viewer do a couple of sessions, then you give the sessions and the feedback-pics and cues to some other people and let them decide which skeds fit which targets. You can then access the probablilty of those people fitting the right sessions to the target by chance, and can compare the results to that probability of chance hits. You have to repeat that process a couple of times (depending on the expected effect-size) and you have to make sure you don´t get interference by some other possible effects. You have to make sure you don´t pre-select the sessions you put through this evaluation. And you have to make sure you don´t leak any information to the people that do the fitting (you should not even have someone who knows about what goes together in the room, people are great at subconciously reading body-language). That´s why you have to use a double-blind design to do this testing.
Valtra Wrote:
The fact that Prof. Truzzi didn’t consider the validity of those two sessions, means that he is essentially calling the viewer a liar and a cheat. What else is there? Beyond that, it implies that the skeptic is in such a mind-lock that he can’t see outside his own box.
His thought processing is an endless closed-loop.
Me:
There is the possiblity, that the viewer really believes that he is on to something even though he might only get chance-hits. In social-science you always have to check for the possiblity of chance results. If you try to figure out if there are more men employed in a profession and you have found that there are 60 men and 40 women in your survey in that profession, you can´t just jump in there and say „yeah, there must be a reason that prevents women from entering that profession" , you have to first check for the probabillity of picking more men than women by chance. There are some statistical procedures for that. Did stuff like that myself. If you are interested, I could send you an Adobe-Acrobat Version of the Handbook for the Software I use. It´s in English, and got lot´s of examples.
Valtra wrote:
It is not to convince the skeptic that it is real but to actually put RVing to task so that it has application in reality. In other words, PROVE IT IN REALITY! Our efforts are better spent to find that missing child, uncover the mystery…..help improve the human condition in some way.
Me:
That´s got nothing to do with Truzzi calling himself a skeptic. With the data you provided, people like Puthoff or Targ would have told you that´s not sufficient.
Truzzi did not state that he is willing to believe in anything without scientific testing. He just stated that Pseudo-Skeptics are not even satisfied with that kind of testing and want to push the scientific standards on anomalies-research to a level that can not be maintained, even though it is already much higher than in most other fields of research.
Convincing Pseudo-Skeptics is almost impossible, but with the Data you provide you could not convince any Scientist (from his professional point of view, and from that point of view one should give a damn about his own personal believes when the results are in). It´s not about proving it to Pseudo-Skeptics, It´s about proving it scientifically. Like I said before: I (personally) believe the HRVG is doing an amazing job and I am doing fine :-). If you ask me as a student of sociology or physics I can only tell you: I don´t know. Neither sociological or physical theories (I am not really good in Quantum-Mechanics, but from what I know it does not look good) provide for this phenomenon and I have not seen any convincing scientific results that conclude the phenomenon is more than chance-hits. And I am not schitzophrenic :-). That´s two completely different things. Don´t get them mixed up.
There is nothing wrong with giving a damn about scientific procedures and going on with training and practical application. Scientifc evaluation needs lot´s of thought put into and then it is lot´s of dull gathering of data and doing statistics. When you don´t feel the results will justify this trouble then don´t do it, but then you should admit that and stop blaming Skeptics. If you conduct scientific research and they still won´t accept your data, then you might (if you really did everything right) have a point of accusing them of being pseudo-skeptics, with double-standards.
So, if I were you, I would take down that Editorial for now, scoop up a detailed test-design (I would offer to do that, but I think your Psychology PhD can do a much better job than me, I really don´t care that much about quantitative research), contact Mr. Truzzi, ask if he thinks the design is sufficient or if he got any suggestions on it´s improvement and then conduct the tests according to that design. If he then still does not accept the results, then you got something to blast him BIG. This Editorial just does not do any good. It does not prove anything since you and Mr. Truzzi are talking about different things. He´s been taling about scientific evaluation and you have been talking about seeing and believing. Different things, no point in your argumentation. Whole editorial just angry and personal. I understand your feelings, but that editorial is still not good style.
Bye,
Jan.
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Aloha Jan,
Perhaps you have by-passed an exciting career in Law. You make your case very clearly and eloquently. I commend you on the thought and care you express in your post.
Whether or not the Editorial stays or moves to the archives is a decision for Dick. It is after all an Editorial based on his personal on the ground experience with Mr. Truzzi. An Editorial being an expression of the opinion of its’ writer.
The dilemma here is that Mr. Truzzi is presumed by many to be a friend to RV and even sits on the board at the IRVA. Is it a case of bad manners to challenge the skeptical identity of Mr. Truzzi? Is that challenge more or less than his challenge to Dick’s questions? Should Dick defer to Mr. Truzzi as a protocol of politeness?
The conference was not intended to be a display of critical scientific evidence for the case for RV. It was a gathering of those in the community to meet and exchange information and ideas. For the Skeptic in attendance to expect the presentation of scientifically quantified data from its attendees or the application of such to displayed raw data is a bit unrealistic.
This means that at such an event as the conference there is no evidence for the skeptic and there is nothing that can be said to a skeptic that will really make a difference. So nothing can really be accomplished.
I think that evidence needs to be presented to qualified members of the scientific community in the laboratory. Mr. Truzzi’s Sociology background although laudable should yield to those more qualified in other fields of more critical science. His convincing is somehow less urgent.
To derail Remote Viewing towards the endlessly convincing of skeptics is wrong. The Studies conducted by qualified scientists at SRI, OSI, etc quantifies the existence of the phenomena. The operations conducted by the military demonstrate the application of the skill. The challenge to the viewers should not be to have to battle the skeptics to get RV into the scientific arena but to do their best work to give science as clean a sample of the RV product as possible.
Not to put words in his mouth but his statement "Well that’s just too good. I couldn’t believe that." Really means, "Even if this is true…I wouldn’t believe it." This is what makes my alarms go off.
Jan I would say that no body of work generated by Remote Viewers would be acceptable to any skeptic. Whether it was session work or tabulated statistics. Their identity remains intact as skeptics only as long as that which they are skeptical of remains outside the bounds of their doubt. In his own words Mr. Truzzi says that he is a hard-core skeptic.
I am afraid there is no data that any of us in the community possess that is acceptable. No information and no statistics we have collected are admissible as evidence to the skeptic. The control of the evaluation cannot be trusted to us in the skeptic’s eyes. So to Dick I would say your questions to Mr. Truzzi were an exercise in futility. But you did not know that at the time because you were lulled into believing he was approachable as a result of his lecture.
In that light we need to realize that all of us in the RV community are indeed on an equal footing with the skeptic. All of us, the Smiths the Buchanan’s, the Swann’s, the Carr’s, the Browns, the Dames’s the Dourif’s and every other name of any countless number of remote viewers. There is nothing any of us can do within the purview of our organizations to convince a skeptic. We need Investigative science not investigate doubt.
MY advice is to terminate all rapport with skeptics and seek out those elements of Science who will just do what they do best. Experiment, hypothesize, and publish. Then let the chips fall where they may.
Aloha Glenn
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Aloha Jan,
Moin Glenn,
Perhaps you have by-passed an exciting career in Law. You make your case very clearly and eloquently. I commend you on the thought and care you express in your post.
I would starve to death as a Lawer. I´d really have a hard time either rejecting to many cases or doing a very bad job for my clients, because I would probably not fully agree with them or see to much of both sides in the argument.
And like I just said on chat today: I don´t want to use my powers for evil :-)
Whether or not the Editorial stays or moves to the archives is a decision for Dick. It is after all an Editorial based on his personal on the ground experience with Mr. Truzzi. An Editorial being an expression of the opinion of its’ writer.
The dilemma here is that Mr. Truzzi is presumed by many to be a friend to RV and even sits on the board at the IRVA. Is it a case of bad manners to challenge the skeptical identity of Mr. Truzzi? Is that challenge more or less than his challenge to Dick’s questions? Should Dick defer to Mr. Truzzi as a protocol of politeness?
No, that has got nothing to do with defering, but with putting up the fight in the right arena. This editorial puts the fight on the arena of personal believes. It would have been much better style to fight the battle on the scientific level.
I think it would have also been nice to contact Mr. Truzzi and to discuss his position. Was not there at the conference, but maybe there was some misunderstanding? Maybe he was tired got a heart-burn and sore feet and then was just baffeled by your skeds and over-reacted? I figured that most conflicts turn to nothing when you take some time to ask some questions and listen. Well Dick is trained to ask questions and to listen, but his job is to make conflicts go public and not disappear :-)
Since you feel, that Mr. Truzzi would cheat on that confrontation with scientific evidence, and would not be helpful to our cause, it is quite understandable that you don´t want to carry the whole thing to this level. Under these circumstances I would not want to do that either. After all, getting the scientific data is loads of work.
The conference was not intended to be a display of critical scientific evidence for the case for RV. It was a gathering of those in the community to meet and exchange information and ideas. For the Skeptic in attendance to expect the presentation of scientifically quantified data from its attendees or the application of such to displayed raw data is a bit unrealistic.
This means that at such an event as the conference there is no evidence for the skeptic and there is nothing that can be said to a skeptic that will really make a difference. So nothing can really be accomplished.
I think that evidence needs to be presented to qualified members of the scientific community in the laboratory. Mr. Truzzi’s Sociology background although laudable should yield to those more qualified in other fields of more critical science. His convincing is somehow less urgent.
Na, must disagree. Sociology is the most important :-)
BTW, just have finished a book by a german parapsychologist, that suggests that Psi-effects diminish through repeated testing because of observer-effects.
To derail Remote Viewing towards the endlessly convincing of skeptics is wrong. The Studies conducted by qualified scientists at SRI, OSI, etc quantifies the existence of the phenomena. The operations conducted by the military demonstrate the application of the skill. The challenge to the viewers should not be to have to battle the skeptics to get RV into the scientific arena but to do their best work to give science as clean a sample of the RV product as possible.
Not to put words in his mouth but his statement "Well that’s just too good. I couldn’t believe that." Really means, "Even if this is true…I wouldn’t believe it." This is what makes my alarms go off.
Jan I would say that no body of work generated by Remote Viewers would be acceptable to any skeptic. Whether it was session work or tabulated statistics. Their identity remains intact as skeptics only as long as that which they are skeptical of remains outside the bounds of their doubt. In his own words Mr. Truzzi says that he is a hard-core skeptic.
I am afraid there is no data that any of us in the community possess that is acceptable. No information and no statistics we have collected are admissible as evidence to the skeptic. The control of the evaluation cannot be trusted to us in the skeptic’s eyes. So to Dick I would say your questions to Mr. Truzzi were an exercise in futility. But you did not know that at the time because you were lulled into believing he was approachable as a result of his lecture.
In that light we need to realize that all of us in the RV community are indeed on an equal footing with the skeptic. All of us, the Smiths the Buchanan’s, the Swann’s, the Carr’s, the Browns, the Dames’s the Dourif’s and every other name of any countless number of remote viewers. There is nothing any of us can do within the purview of our organizations to convince a skeptic. We need Investigative science not investigate doubt.
MY advice is to terminate all rapport with skeptics and seek out those elements of Science who will just do what they do best. Experiment, hypothesize, and publish. Then let the chips fall where they may.
Aloha Glenn
Bye,
Jan.
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Aloha Jan,
If I can comment on something you said :)
BTW, just have finished a book by a german parapsychologist, that suggests that Psi-effects diminish through repeated testing because of observer-effects.
It seems from time to time that some people have never put together 2 & 2. I know from my RV work that the energy required to produce results is well worth examining. After session work I crave sugar (which is bad) and feel exhausted in a different way than from physical effort. It also seems when I start out fresh that there is a limited amount of energy that I have to apply towards the target. I think we use energy from some source within us that does get depleted. It then takes a bit of time to rebuild. Is this some form of psychic energy?? I could not say. This explains the reason for diminishing results during testing. That along with the psychology of boredom from repetive test for which there is little or no reward or sense of accomplishment.
ALoha Glenn
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Well, that little editorial generated some interesting discussion, so in that sense it was a success.
Now if we can get the regular section up for Max, things could get very interesting.
Aloha
Dick
Re: Editorial on M. Truzzi
Glenn – That’s an interesting comment re the craving for sugar after a Remote viewing session. I find that after doing a hands-on Reiki (energy "healing" work) session with a client, that I crave salty food and/or sugar (Bring on the Mr. Pretzels and marshmallows!) along with water. I don’t find "craving" to be the case (at least not to the same degree) when I do "distant" or "absentee" Reiki (the client is anywhere but with me…sometimes 10,000 miles away).
In both cases (hands-on and absentee), I find not too much of an energy depletion afterwards, except in unusual cases. I wonder if that’s related to the "attunements" involved during Reiki training. My understanding is that these attunements open up one’s energy "channel" to allow energy to flow through the practitioner versus the practitioner using (and depleting) their own energy.
It would be interesting to know if Reiki attunements help one "conserve" energy during remote viewing :-)
Kathy
~~~~~
I know from my RV work that the energy required to produce results is well worth examining. After session work I crave sugar (which is bad) and feel exhausted in a different way than from physical effort. It also seems when I start out fresh that there is a limited amount of energy that I have to apply towards the target. I think we use energy from some source within us that does get depleted. It then takes a bit of time to rebuild. Is this some form of psychic energy?? I could not say. This explains the reason for diminishing results during testing. That along with the psychology of boredom from repetive test for which there is little or no reward or sense of accomplishment.
ALoha Glenn