Triad Area Skeptics Club
The May/June issue of Skeptical Inquirer has a two column article about a RV test conducted by TASC with
some HRVG people. They claim the results did not produce hits and apparently the HRVG participants will not try again nor work with TASC to "develop a more reliable protocol" whatever they had in mind…
When did this occur?
Re: Triad Area Skeptics Club
Rich,
HRVG never took part in any test with either of the organizations you mention.
A member of our group did conduct something on his own, not as part of the Guild. There were problems with the testing protocols. None the less some fairly amazing results occurred, which tend to support remote viewing. One of the "skeptics" admitted being intrigued by the results. You can get more details by emailing Jimmy Williams (cooljerk@hawaii.rr.com)
I have read the Skeptical Enquirer. This journal ignores facts and promotes debunking without regard to the truth. As an award winning journalist with 25 years experience I would call the Skeptical Enquirer- let me see… would "worthless piece of garbage" be putting it too strongly?
HRVG has officially participated in ONLY one skeptic test. The skeptic ran a con on us and violated the terms of the test. In spite of his attempted scam, he was the only person who knew the cue, and the only person in possession of the target photo.
The following sketch was produced:
Re: Triad Area Skeptics Club
Hi Rich,
We did a test last November. There is a link in the article about Hawaii Remote Viewing that is my reply to the article.
If you look at the images that we got during the test, you will agree that some amazing remote viewing occured. Unfortunately we weren’t able to perform according to the criteria of the test. In my opinion the root cause is an inadequate understanding and facility to target the images.
The article I wrote in response can be read at:
home.hawaii.rr.com/cooljerk/
Aloha, Jimmy
The May/June issue of Skeptical Inquirer has a two column article about a RV test conducted by TASC with some HRVG people. They claim the results did not produce hits and apparently the HRVG participants will not try again nor work with TASC to "develop a more reliable protocol" whatever they had in mind…
When did this occur?
Re: Triad Area Skeptics Club
Aloha Jimmy,
A very nice presentation. Good work and I know someday you’ll figure out how to wrestle one of these skeptics to the mat and make them say uncle :)
Aloha Glenn
Re: Triad Area Skeptics Club
Hi Rich, We did a test last November. There is a link in the article about Hawaii Remote Viewing that is my reply to the article. If you look at the images that we got during the test, you will agree that some amazing remote viewing occured. Unfortunately we weren’t able to perform according to the criteria of the test. In my opinion the root cause is an inadequate understanding and facility to target the images. The article I wrote in response can be read at: home.hawaii.rr.com/cooljerk/ Aloha, Jimmy
I think it was a great experiment if for nothing else than the fact you all were willing to do it.
It seems that setting up the conditions of tests very often is the major stumbling block. Farsight had similar problems. Its very frustrating for the spectators like me to hear about these types of problems, kinda like having the Indy 500 rained out and not being able to make the rain date. :)
It would seem that a trial run is an absolute requirement to iron out any mis-conceptions. Also, unless one is taking the Psi-Tech position of infallibility, there has to be room for error, partially correct or vague results and outright misses as well as the home runs.
I do hope you will give it another try because from your data, it looks like it should have been a successful experiment. Actually, I don’t really understand where it went wrong. I will have to read your comment sover again.
The possible overlay problem you speculate about has come up often in RV discussions. It has advocates and dissenters but no research to back up either position.
I am curious as to what sort of protocol TASC suggested as an improvement.
Again, its great to see someone get up on stage.
Rich
Re: Triad Area Skeptics Club
I have read the Skeptical Enquirer. This journal ignores facts and promotes debunking without regard to the truth. As an award winning journalist with 25 years experience I would call the Skeptical Enquirer- let me see… would "worthless piece of garbage" be putting it too strongly?
heheheh. Is that the other side of the coin that describes Psi-Tech? They both claim infallibility in their own ways.
I don’t agree with all of their views anymore than I accept all of the various paranormal, RV and ET stories
out there. However, they are a good source of documentation for dis-assembling some of the more flagrant hoaxes that are spawned almost monthly and launched to the world by Art Bell and Co.
If you can point me to some other source that analyses and discusses secrete bible codes, Nostradamus prophocies, what Jean Dixon really said, MJ-12 documants, reverse speech, etc, etc, etc I would appreciate it.
One other thing I like about them is that they don’t hesitate to name who they are talking about unlike many
others.
I don’t know how many times they may have blamed Venus for UFO sightings, but anyone who feels George Adamski was uuhhhhh…..mistaken…..scores a few points with me. :)
Rich
Re: Triad Area Skeptics Club
Well said Rich. I do not regret having taken up the challenge. I think it is important for us to stick our neck out. New frontiers are not opened up by the timid. The most important thing to hold on to is our integrity. As long as we stay honest and straight, we have nothing to fear and a whole lot to gain.
TASC did not set up the protocols for the last test, Dr, Carlson was very cooperative though. We have had some bad experiences with skeptics in the past. I can say with all honesty that I would be willing to work with this one again.
If we can come up with a new set of test criteria that would mitigate the problems of the last test, I think we could get enough viewers to try it again.
If anyone has any suggestions for improvement, I’d love to hear them.
Aloha, Jimmy
I think it was a great experiment if for nothing else than the fact you all were willing to do it.
It seems that setting up the conditions of tests very often is the major stumbling block. Farsight had similar problems. Its very frustrating for the spectators like me to hear about these types of problems, kinda like having the Indy 500 rained out and not being able to make the rain date. :)
It would seem that a trial run is an absolute requirement to iron out any mis-conceptions. Also, unless one is taking the Psi-Tech position of infallibility, there has to be room for error, partially correct or vague results and outright misses as well as the home runs.
I do hope you will give it another try because from your data, it looks like it should have been a successful experiment. Actually, I don’t really understand where it went wrong. I will have to read your comment sover again.
The possible overlay problem you speculate about has come up often in RV discussions. It has advocates and dissenters but no research to back up either position.
I am curious as to what sort of protocol TASC suggested as an improvement.
Again, its great to see someone get up on stage.
Rich
Re: Triad Area Skeptics Club
If we can come up with a new set of test criteria that would mitigate the problems of the last test, I think we could get enough viewers to try it again. If anyone has any suggestions for improvement, I’d love to hear them. Aloha, Jimmy
I wander between the simplistic and the complex. I have
often wondered why a simple target vs results series of experiments is not sufficient, similar to what HRVG posts and what farsight is now posting. I’m guesing that a problem is that scoring can be ambiguous except in extremely "dead on" graphically accurate hits or completely off the wall misses.
Of course there is the simple "What’s in the box?" type of RV/psi test but I find no examples of that type of RV beyond the early SRI tests. This "pick the correct picture" type test seems the most popular for some reason.
Maybe Marcello Truzi will discuss this in Mesquite.
Rich
Re: Triad Area Skeptics Club
Hi Rich,
I have watched you post for quite some time now. You ask some pretty insightful questions, and you do your best to keep folks honest. I look forward to meeting you in person at the conference next month.
All the time you have spent investigating remote viewing- you really ought to take a class one of these days and try it for yourself. Take Pru’s one week class, or an intro class from Lyn Buchanan or Paul Smith.
I think you would find it very interesting, and you would probably do something that would cause you to amaze yourself.
When you get into remote viewing you realize that:
1) It really does work.
2) Grandiose claims are mostly BS.
The truth is somewhere in the middle.
The skeptics are not right. They don’t want to see or understand, so they will find a reason not too. On the other hand Ed Dames- there are no serious, legitimate remote viewers who take him seriously.
Talk to you at the conference.
Aloha,
Dick
Re: Triad Area Skeptics Club
Hi Rich, I have watched you post for quite some time now. You ask some pretty insightful questions, and you do your best to keep folks honest. I look forward to meeting you in person at the conference next month.
All the time you have spent investigating remote viewing- you really ought to take a class one of these days and try it for yourself.
—————————
O-L-D e-mail from me to you 10/19/97
—————————
Hi Dick,Are you a member of Firedocs e-mail group? Questions like yours havegotten very comprehensive answers there. Several military CRVersexchange info there almost daily.
—————————
Guess you have forgotten. I have taken a class from Paul and did try the HRVG on line class for a while.
My personal RV has been a few ups and a lot of downs with long gaps of inactivity replaced by too much time
looking for whats RV newsworthy in the days A-F-T-E-R Stargate. By newsworthy I mean either intrinsically useful for private or public good or just a general show-stopper (ala Dames) to wow the skeptics (as well as myself….I like to see homers too.)
Of course, there is the RV Roast site where I get rid of some RV frustrations…heheh. HRVG and greg’s ARV ( tried his online class too ) and now Brown are the few places where one can see actual session work.
—–Remember how secretive it once was???
Anywhoo…..I recently have had some pretty darn good sessions that finally gave me some real intense AIs which always have given me a problem and have just mentioned it on the Stargate e-mail group. Of course, that’s not a HRVG thing but you know it from your SRV training.
Of course, once all the basics are worked out….it will be time to tackle the UFO connection. :):):)
Jim Marrs is at it again ….www.alienzoo.com/home.cfm
Looking foreward to meeting you.
Rich
followup on target pools
I found this in the book Mind Race. Definately not a new problem…..:)
>
Mind Race…Targ and Harary
p 18 One problem that often comes up in traditional psi experiments is that a viewer may accurately describe a picture that is in the pool of possible targets, but not the specific picture that has been designated as the target for that session. In psi research, this all-to-common phenomen is called displacement. We consider displacement to be a type of psychic noise.
This is our reasoning: When an experimenter brings a group of pictures together in a psi experiment, he effectively places th epictures in a "psychic bubble". The pictures may be very different from one another, but they become psychically associated by all being put in the same target pool. So a viewer who tries to describe the designated target picture may have difficulty distinguishing that picture from the
others in the pool. He may describe details of more than one picture, or give an excellent description of one that was not chosen as that session’s target.
In contrast, geographical remote-viewing sessions rarely produce displacement, perhaps because geographical targets cannot be collected in one place- they stay put. Instead, the target site is randomly chosen from a list of various geographical locations. Possibly because written material makes a poor tarfet for psychic perception, the list itself does not generate psychic noise, the way a collection of actual possible targets would.
Re: followup on target pools
Thanks Rich!
This is an exact description of what we encountered in the James Randi Challenge. I was unaware of this phenomenon.
I am unclear on the specifics of geographic remote viewing. Most of the targets cued were specific targets at widely separated sites. What is the distinction?
Aloha, Jimmy
I found this in the book Mind Race. Definately not a new problem…..:) Mind Race…Targ and Harary
p 18 One problem that often comes up in traditional psi experiments is that a viewer may accurately describe a picture that is in the pool of possible targets, but not the specific picture that has been designated as the target for that session. In psi research, this all-to-common phenomen is called displacement. We consider displacement to be a type of psychic noise.
This is our reasoning: When an experimenter brings a group of pictures together in a psi experiment, he effectively places th epictures in a "psychic bubble". The pictures may be very different from one another, but they become psychically associated by all being put in the same target pool. So a viewer who tries to describe the designated target picture may have difficulty distinguishing that picture from the others in the pool. He may describe details of more than one picture, or give an excellent description of one that was not chosen as that session’s target.
In contrast, geographical remote-viewing sessions rarely produce displacement, perhaps because geographical targets cannot be collected in one place- they stay put. Instead, the target site is randomly chosen from a list of various geographical locations. Possibly because written material makes a poor tarfet for psychic perception, the list itself does not generate psychic noise, the way a collection of actual possible targets would.
>